patching...
Update: Worried about your commute? Check out our traffic map. »
Welcome back, Patch Blogger!

Obamacare Medicaid Expansion: Florida House Panel Says No Thanks

It’s looking like Gov. Rick Scott’s decision to go along this major plank in the Obamacare plan is getting a frigid reception from State lawmakers. What do you think about it Tampa Bay?

 

Florida Gov. Rick Scott’s recent flip-flop on Obamacare might be a moot point. It looks like the plan to expand the state’s Medicaid coverage to another 1 million or so people is falling flat with other Florida lawmakers.

A state House committee recently decided that expanding Medicaid to provide care for the uninsured wasn’t the way to go, according to a report on TBO.com. Committee members, TBO reported, said they were concerned about the quality of care and the costs associated with the proposal.

Scott recently said he’d go along with the notion of expanding Medicaid since the federal government would be paying for it for the first three years as part of the Obamacare package, which is more formally known as the Affordable Care Act.

The Florida Senate has yet to take up the issue. Legislative approval is required for the expansion to move forward.

Does the state need to find a better way for the uninsured to receive medical care?

According to state Rep. Richard Corcoran, R-Land O’ Lakes, the answer is yes.

But, “Medicaid expansion is not it,” TBO reported him as saying.

So what do you think, Tampa Bay? Do you agree with Corcoran that expanding Medicaid isn’t the way to go? How would you provide coverage for the estimated 1.3 million people the expansion would help? Or, do you think the state needs to stay out of the healthcare business as much as possible? Share your thoughts in the comments section. 

About this column: What's Tampa Bay Saying is an occasional column that features local, state or national news that we want to get the entire region's take on. These stories are posted on the various local Patch sites throughout Tampa Bay. That way, you can see what your neighbors think, as well as some of the different opinions that make each part of Tampa Bay so unique. We'll follow each column with a roundup of the very best local comments on our individual Patch sites so you can see exactly what readers in your community had to say about a particular topic. Related Topics: Rich Corcoran, medicaid expansion, obamacare, rick scott, and the fit life: sports & wellness guide

-Ed Harris-

4:33 pm on Monday, March 4, 2013

Our Romney/Ryan filled state Capitol would rather see this segment saddle hospitals with bill, truth be told they really just don't care since that segment of people don't vote for them. This problem will not go away and will only be resolved after we fire most of the people in Tallahassee!

Reply
Comment_arrow

sharon poole

8:29 am on Tuesday, March 5, 2013

I disagree. They know the program is financially unsustainable and bankrupt already, it is unfunded and people are going to be shocked next year when they see their premiums go through the roof. This country is broke but no one seems to understand that fact. We simply cannot afford this monstrosity called the "Affordable Care Act", which is anything but. Just wait, you will see my words all come true in just another year or two. Everyone is going to freak out because they did not educate themselves about this horrible law being foisted upon us.

Comment_arrow

Dharma

2:37 pm on Tuesday, March 5, 2013

I took this unit not realizing the building was going forward this year, I was told by the owner before I took it the building would begin next year. Since then he has changed his mind and they will begin June of this year. And to Sharon not all things can be bankrupt you haven’t any idea of what you’re talking about. Seriously, you don’t. Nothing is bankrupted unless all is.

Comment_arrow

Concerned Floridian

5:05 pm on Tuesday, March 5, 2013

"Mooching Off Medicaid" by Paul Krugman, an economist and Nobel prize laureate:
<http://www.nytimes.com/2013/03/04/opinion/krugman-mooching-off-medicare.html?hp&_r=1&>;
.... excerpt:
"Mr. Scott recently shocked Tea Party activists by announcing his support for the Medicaid expansion. But his support came with a condition: he was willing to cover more of the uninsured only after receiving a waiver that would let him run Medicaid through private insurance companies. Now, why would he want to do that?"

Comment_arrow

Ajay Jain

12:32 pm on Friday, March 29, 2013

Hello Friends,

Governor Rick Perry millions of under-privileged poor Texans who do not have any Health Coverage will be covered under The Affordable Care ACT (ACA) expansion of MEDICAID!

My Physician wife's practice is partly dependent on MEDICAID and its viability.
Please allow the expansion of MEDICAID to occur in Texas under The Affordable Care ACT. If states choose to expand Medicaid, the federal government will cover 100 percent of the costs from 2014 to 2016. The feds' contribution will begin to decrease in 2017, but will never be less than 90 percent, under the ACA.

That's why I created a petition to Governor Rick Perry, Texas Governor, The Texas State House, The Texas State Senate, and Governor Rick Perry, which
says:

"Please ACCEPT the FREE EXPANSION of MEDICAID under The Affordable Care ACT."

Will you sign this petition? Click here:

http://signon.org/sign/accept-free-expansion?source=c.em.cp&r_by=7268737

Thanks!

Ajay Jain
ajain31@gmail.com
Twitter Handle ajain31
Mobile: 214-207-9781

-Ed Harris-

4:51 pm on Monday, March 4, 2013

Tallahassee seems to only have a handful of Republicans, Democrats and Independents that seem to know what their doing. The rest need to go and take the governor with them!

Reply

Patriot

4:52 pm on Monday, March 4, 2013

Thank you Tallahassee for getting this one right! Shame on you Rick Scott for falling for the Obama pay off scam!

Reply
Comment_arrow

Grace

6:47 pm on Monday, March 4, 2013

Shame on anybody who voted for any of them in Tallahassee! TERM LIMITS FOR ALL POLITICIANS!

Comment_arrow

Rider

7:42 pm on Monday, March 4, 2013

Obamacare is modeled after the successful Romneycare program in Mass

Comment_arrow

E. Niles

7:04 am on Tuesday, March 5, 2013

Interesting to note you see yourself as a patriot. I assume you consider anyone else who differs with your opinions is unAmerican. You, like the rest of us, will, of course, have to pay for the 1.3 million uninsured persons with higher hospital charges and mounting medical costs. Scott should know--he ran hospitals before becoming governor.

Comment_arrow

sharon poole

8:33 am on Tuesday, March 5, 2013

I agree with your comment. Rick Scott has lost a lot of respect from me.

Comment_arrow

Patriot

8:47 am on Tuesday, March 5, 2013

E.Niles: When it comes to GOVERNMENT, less is more! Obamacare is way to much GOVERNMENT! Health system has issues, but GOVERNMENT take over is not the answer! And yes, I would continue to pay for the uninsured then hand over my healthcare to the GOVERNMENT.

Comment_arrow

Donna Carroll Erlandson

8:48 am on Tuesday, March 5, 2013

To GRACE, I totally AGREE with you, term limits for ALL Politicians !!! Kudos to you :)

Comment_arrow

Patriot

8:51 am on Tuesday, March 5, 2013

Rider: It is often asserted that RomneyCare is the same thing as ObamaCare, but this is simply not true. It is important to note that Massachusetts, the state where Romneycare was founded, opposed Obamacare. In fact, Massachusetts opposed Obamacare so much that they elected Senator Scott Brown (R) in 2010 to be the deciding vote against Obamacare after Senator Ted Kennedy’s death. Why would the state where Romneycare was founded be opposed to Obamacare if the two laws were really the same? The answer is, of course, that they are not the same. While there are similarities between the two laws, there are also key differences. Below is a table of differences between the Romney plan and the Obama plan

Comment_arrow

Torrey Craig

11:39 am on Tuesday, March 5, 2013

Do you have an alternative that is actionable? Or do we simply cast those aside who fail to have the necessary means to afford reasonable health care? Perhaps Sir ... you would find yourself in agreement with the individual who attended the Republican Candidates debate here in Tampa. When Ron Paul was advancing his ideas on health care one member of the audience cried out "DIE." Do you find yourself in agreement with statement, or perhaps that was you?

-Ed Harris-

4:56 pm on Monday, March 4, 2013

Lol it was the Republican plan lololol So if its a scam it is the Dole scam! Lololol

Reply
Comment_arrow

Patriot

4:58 pm on Monday, March 4, 2013

Damn Republicans and Dems!

Martha Dunningham

5:23 pm on Monday, March 4, 2013

Typical Tallahassee! Ignore the problem and it will go away! Look out ER's it's going to get busier!

Reply

JOHN

5:25 pm on Monday, March 4, 2013

My wife just got out of the hospital last week, we have NO medical insurance, nothing...so right, it's our fault right?The hospital Dr. Only gave her enough medications for less than two weeks, we're trying to find a Dr. who'll renew her med prescriptions...NONE are willing On the same day we got out of the hospital we visited several doctors, we're looking for a primary doctor and a heart doctor. As well as a few others. The first thing they ( the staff) asked us was , what insurance do you have, we said we haven't got any, they said sorry we can't see you because we have no insurance....we saw another Dr. and they said that if we get on Medicaid , they may help us.....we are relying on Florida's medicaid system to help my wife who's 71 years of age. If we are turned away from medicaid and my wife can't get her medications renewed , you can tell
state Rep. Richard Corcoran, R-Land O’ Lakes, and ALL others that they will be receiving a lawsuit for their decision if anything happens to my wife.. This is a promise. WE NEED MEDICAID TO HELP US!!!

Reply
Comment_arrow

Peggy Jamison

5:32 pm on Monday, March 4, 2013

There should be a way to hold lawmakers responsible for bad judgment that affects the people they're supposed to be representing!

Comment_arrow

michael mirra

11:51 pm on Monday, March 4, 2013

Republicans don't care. They have no heart. How can anyone vote against medical care for people in need? Remember, God IS watching us from a distance. There is a judgment. Those heartless bastards.

Comment_arrow

sharon poole

8:26 am on Tuesday, March 5, 2013

Why is it the responsibility of the state of Florida to provide free health insurance for your wife? Why have you not applied for Medicare or Medicaid a long time ago? If your income is too high for Medicaid then you should at least have applied for Medicare for your wife. And yes, I do blame you, unless you are truly destitute/homeless. And if that is the case, you already have Medicaid available to you. And if you can afford to sue people, then you must have a lot of money stashed away somewhere. Because lawyers aren't cheap.

Comment_arrow

sparky

8:31 am on Tuesday, March 5, 2013

Wait, your wife is 71 and NOT on Medicare already? Something smells in this post. If you at your age are collecting social security and think you don't need Medicare because the rest of society should pay for ignorance, well good luck in the short time you have in life.

Comment_arrow

Donna Carroll Erlandson

8:57 am on Tuesday, March 5, 2013

John, I am truly sorry for your wife's illnesses. Is she not on Medicare? She is certainly of age to receive Medicare. Medicare is your insurance. Are you not on Medicare? You must be to be able to pay your bills unless you are still working and that is totally possible. Next time you go to a doctor tell them that your wife is on Medicare. The Medicare number is usually you or your wife's Social Security number. Please apply for Medicare for your wife so that she can receive the help she needs. Thank You. By the way, I am 63 and I am on Medicare and Medicaid and is very helpful to me as I am disabled.

Comment_arrow

Patriot

9:14 am on Tuesday, March 5, 2013

michael mirra: I do not agree with you that REPUBLICANS do not care (I am not a REPUBLICAN by the way). I do think in the long run, Obamacare is not the answer. Government has very poor record globally administering to the health needs of the people. The hard truth is, in a true REPUBLIC (that America is suppose to be) we were all charged with the responsibility of our own individual needs. That means everything, a home, nourishment, and our health. I understand through the years and multiple presidents that driven to take on more socialist welfare programs the great REPUBLIC has been burdened with laws and policies that have slowly taken the power and self responsibility away from the REPUBLIC. Given this, imo, we would do well to slowly remove all social welfare programs and healthcare programs and initiate mandates that provide for the needy through private nonprofits that are funded both by the through the government without government oversight and the people.

Comment_arrow

Wendy Leblanc

9:49 am on Tuesday, March 5, 2013

John - your said your wife is 71 years old. Does she not have Medicare? If not, why not?

Comment_arrow

Michael D.

10:13 am on Tuesday, March 5, 2013

MM,
The usual Republicans don't care, is just as bad as the only thing democrats want is a completely socialism.
It comes down to the follow the money, those who pay for the services will end up making decisions on the services rendered and will hold the records of what illinesses/services the user has. Do I want my government to know what my medical history or issues I have going on are, regardless of how temporary they might be? No one other than a professional I trust should have my records and those of my family.
Also like many government industries that should really be private (USPS) they are run horribly. And honestly should be restructured by someone who understands the organization in question. The government is the wrong organization to be operating a number of functions due to the organizational overhead that it incorporates.

Comment_arrow

michael mirra

10:41 am on Tuesday, March 5, 2013

cutting health benifits to people that need them, like republicans do to john's wife, with no feeling, because it fits some anti-Obama agenda sucks. Plain & simple. People need this healthcare & the federal government is paying, but the Republicans don't give a crap. If Obama proposed it, they MUST oppose it.

Comment_arrow

Michael D.

10:52 am on Tuesday, March 5, 2013

I like how it is only the Republicans that do this not that both parties made this decision. Your bias, and it is as extreme as the people you speak out against on the extreme right. You are so busy finger pointing, you don't see the real problem. You see the trees but not the forest of issues within our government organization. The government isn't responsible for every issue. If they were, do you blame the government for the "accounting" practices of Eron? It would also mean that the government is at fault for the gas prices? Could it be that we are in such a litigious society that medical insurance has risen to the point where doctors can't afford to see a patient without decent insurance? But that is the government's fault to? Or according to you, the Republican's fault, because Democrats can make no bad decisions. By the way both parties voted this down, not just the Republicans. You know why, because there are a lot of problems with. Read the actual Affordable Health Care Act Bill and you will see that.

Comment_arrow

Peggy Jamison

2:58 pm on Tuesday, March 5, 2013

John, obviously the large majority of people here don't realize that medicare doesn't pay for many meds, you have to get a seperate policy for that, which costs money, and if you're like my Mom, and get $850 a month social security to live on, sometimes that's not possible. Try going online to the medicine manufacturer and apply for help. Some of the meds I take are $1000 a bottle. They give it to low income people for free or on a sliding scale. I only pay $200, which still hurts! My so called new "insurance" won't pay anything on it. Good luck, it's too bad these bad things had to happen to you late in life when it's a lot harder to cope. My prayers are with you and your wife.

Comment_arrow

Mark

3:53 am on Wednesday, March 6, 2013

I wish I was only 1/10th as smart as michael mirra THINKS he is. I AM a Republican and I DO have a heart. Because I oppose Obamacare for its unintended negative consequences, which I feel far outweigh its benefits, does not mean I am heartless. michael mirra, while attempting to portray himself as deep, has actually exposed his shallowness.

Peggy Jamison

5:27 pm on Monday, March 4, 2013

"they were concerned about the quality of care and the costs associated with the proposal." Don't these people realize that #1, they could be in the same position as those of us that have gotten sick and lost our insurance? Unless They were born with a silver spoon, who can pay hospital bills now days without ins.#2 We don't not have ins by choice, or because we don't take responsibility for ourselves (47% remark) the insurance companies WILL NOT cover you once you've had a significant health problem and lost your insurance because of it. Many people just get sicker every day to the point they CAN"T go back to work because they can't afford care or meds. That means more welfare and medicare whether we like it or not. If we take care of the sick people, who never asked to be sick and lose their ins in the first place, they CAN go back to work. That won't cost more.. it'll save taxpayer $$$$!

Reply
Comment_arrow

sharon poole

8:22 am on Tuesday, March 5, 2013

Peggy, insurance companies no longer can reject you for pre-existing conditions, nor can they drop you for making a claim. That is a huge part of the new "Affordable Care Act" law, which is completely unaffordable, and which will take full effect, supposedly, next year. So get ready for your premiums to absolutely skyrocket, because you are going to be covering all of those pre-existing conditions that may or may not have been self-induced. Also, the Federal government is only guaranteeing to fund the expansion for 3 years. So then what happens? The state has to pick up the tab, which will affect every single tax paying person in the state of Florida. I think the committee is doing the right thing. They don't trust the federal government, and neither do I.

Comment_arrow

sparky

8:38 am on Tuesday, March 5, 2013

Do you have any idea of how irrational your statements are? Why do you not realize that Obamacare takes the money paid to hospitals for ER and other costs for people that do nt have insurance and puts it towards Obamacare? More people will be turned away from quality care in the coming years. What ever happened to the American ideal of self sufficiency ? I am responsible for myself, not a bunch of mooches. Remember the story of the little red hen?

Comment_arrow

Peggy Jamison

2:41 pm on Tuesday, March 5, 2013

Sharon, you obviously don't know what the hell you're talking about... I'm living it. You obviously are not.

orbit1

5:36 pm on Monday, March 4, 2013

Time to Reeeeeeam these Republicans.

Reply
Comment_arrow

Mark

3:45 am on Wednesday, March 6, 2013

Is that what being a Liberal is all about orbit1? Whether you realize it or not Obama is "Reeeeeeaming" us ALL, Democrat or Republican. There's a big storm brewing orbit1. Desperate times are on the horizon. When it strikes, Obamacare will not matter because our system and our government will have failed us. People will have to learn how to take care of themselves because the government will not be able to after it collapses.

paul

7:37 pm on Monday, March 4, 2013

Growing up I worked many jobs to support myself.When I turned 35 years old,I suffered from an un-expected injury & illness which left me instantly disabled,and then I went to live on the streets homeless 1 year.Theres a flaw in the Medicaid system.The Doctors are very particular about your insurance.They will except the SSI,but they will not accept the secondary insurance which in many cases elderly & disabled people have the Medicaid.So your very limited to your Dr. choice.They will put you through tests because the testing is quick & pays them the highest amount from the Fed & State insurance,BUT,it does not pay them enough money for that Doctor to WANT to give you proper treatment & revisits after the quick tests are performed.Expand Medicaid by creating Federally funded teams of investigators to start cracking down on shady Doctors who except Medicaid & do not render proper services.

Reply
Comment_arrow

Peggy Jamison

9:09 pm on Monday, March 4, 2013

My Dr used to take Medicare, but he quit last summer. He says a medicare payment for a standard appt is Way below what it COSTS him to do the appt. So the extra is coming out of his pocket. He's a good Dr, and a good person, and I can see it pains him not to be able to help, but he does have to make a living. Where is all the money going? If we can't afford to help with peoples medical bills, why are we so far in debt? Maybe we should just tear it all down and start from the bottom up. So many wasteful practices, so many people who CAN not paying their fair share. I'm ashamed of my countrymen sometimes!

Comment_arrow

sharon poole

8:16 am on Tuesday, March 5, 2013

You have touched on an important issue, that Medicaid is a terrible program that is not run correctly as it is now, so why should it be expanded?

Comment_arrow

sparky

8:42 am on Tuesday, March 5, 2013

So all doctors that accept Medicade are shady? And the ones that don't will not have to cheat on the paperwork. Doctors and clinics have to pay their way first before making a profit. Medicade does not pay for a basic level of care so the clinic can survive...and that is the future.

Comment_arrow

Donna Carroll Erlandson

9:24 am on Tuesday, March 5, 2013

@Paul, I totally agree with you. Life "changes on a dime". In 1991, I was 41 and having a good time in my life. One day, out of the blue, I had a stroke. It was from a malformed vessel from birth in my left lower occipital lobe of my brain. There was NO way that I could have known about this sooner. It took me almost one year to get "back to myself". I also had residuals from the stroke. I have stress seizures, night blindness, no periphial in my right eye and memory loss. Short term and long term. I was totally LUCKY that time to have insurance, had I not had it I would have been in a lot of trouble with the care that I received. Doctors who except Medicaid do not render proper services because it take a very long time before they are paid. They seem to not care at all. I see it all the time with my GP here where I live. Most of the time my GP sends his Nurse Asst to the facility (ALF) to see the sick people. To me that is crazy. Medicaid is paying the Dr. NOT the nurse assistant !!!
Makes me wonder if I should not call this Dr. out to Medicaid. What do you readers think I should do?

Comment_arrow

Dad of Three

4:46 pm on Tuesday, March 19, 2013

For all of you complaining about Medicare, or its reimbursements to healthcare providers, you need to get (try the library, if its no longer at the store) the March 4th edition of Time.

The cover article is "Bitter Pill; Why Medical Bills Are Killing Us', written by Steven Brill. The article, in some 31 pages, is an exposé of how Medicare is actually profitable for most healthcare providers, and it demonstrates where money is being wasted because Congress refuses to give Medicare authority to negotiate drug prices, and medical hardware prices, without their hands tied behind their backs by Congress.

It also demonstrates that some parts of the system are being over-compensated, such as hospital executives and top hospital administrators, as well as medical device salesmen and private health insurance company executives, while others, such as family physicians, are somewhat under-compensated.

Medicare works, and Medicare would work even better if Congress did not protect the drug companies and device manufacturers rather than the people who depend upon Medicare.

It is a very revealing read, and cuts through the crap that partisans try to distort in an effort to have their own ideological way.

Steve

9:05 pm on Monday, March 4, 2013

Score one more for the pigs in Tallahassee...

Reply

ptb

9:45 pm on Monday, March 4, 2013

Scott probably said he would accept Obamacare knowing that his republican buddies in the legislature would reject it anyway.This way it makes it look like he really tried but it was the other guys , but please re-elect me anyway ....NOT EVER

Reply

Owen Linder, MD FACP

11:12 pm on Monday, March 4, 2013

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=HVAWI2NPnWA&feature=youtu.be
My January 14th testimony to the House and Senate subcommittees on the PPACA
along with Dr Foriani's, tells this story clearly. Please view it. Dr Linder

Reply
Comment_arrow

Donna Carroll Erlandson

11:11 am on Tuesday, March 5, 2013

Dr. Linder, I was very, very impressed with your testimony in front of the House & Senate Subcommittees. Thank you for taking out time from your practice to do this for ALL of us who need medical help. I am disabled with seizure activity, COPD, both knees bone on bone. I pray that your testimony resonates with some of the people on the panel. Thank you, once more. Donna

Allie's Grandpa

12:51 am on Tuesday, March 5, 2013

Dr Linder

That is certainly compelling testimony; as someone with primary coverage through Medicare, and secondary coverage through Tricare (I'm a retired military officer) I am fortunate, but I want others to also receive the medical care that they need.

You spoke eloquently about a specific case known to you, but we all need to realize that there are millions of similar stories in this nation. Expanding Medicaid in Florida is the very least that we should do.

Reply
Comment_arrow

Peggy Jamison

11:10 am on Tuesday, March 5, 2013

Thank you! I'm tired of being called a "mooch" because I got sick, got let go from my job BECAUSE I was sick, and lost my ins because I lost my job. Couldn't get more because I was SICK. I paid health ins all my life and only used it to have 2 kids. Now, when I need it, I can't get it. To "Sharon Poole" I've been sick with chronic Lyme and out of ins for 15 years. I did finally get ins last year. None of the big companies with decent policies will touch me, and the two companies we have gotten to approve me don't cover even a 10th of the meds and dr's bill's I have. I didn't ask for this, I didn't want it, I used to be an energetic, ambitious, and yes, responsible person! I believe I'm a good person, but when I hear you people going on about it's my fault and people like me ask for what we get, and we aren't responsible, it makes me wish you'd get put in my position. Get sick, lose your job, lose your insurance and find out what wonderful people make up this country. Thank heavens for people like Allie's Grandpa, and Bobby Saltzman maybe there's hope for us yet.

Robert "Bobby" Saltzman

7:15 am on Tuesday, March 5, 2013

Now the money will like the Bullet Train go out of state...

"Does the state need to find a better way for the uninsured to receive medical care?
state Rep. Richard Corcoran, R-Land O’ Lakes, the answer is yes.
But, “Medicaid expansion is not it,”

Like to break it down to I don't give a rats behind about poor people that don;t have access to adequate health care...it's an Obama plan anyway no self respecting Republican would vote for anything Obama...
With a firm grip on the legsialture these clowns will be kicking us around until we smarten up and toss them in the street...

Reply

sharon poole

8:13 am on Tuesday, March 5, 2013

I think the committee did the right thing and I disagree with Scott on accepting federal money for medicaid expansion that is only guaranteed by the federal government for 3 years. Then what? This is just another example of unfunded mandate that is eating this country alive. I think Florida should punt on the entire issue, and let the all-knowing, all-caring, all-everything Fed set everything up and pay for it all. Then they will be exposed for the bumbling fools they are, when they come up empty and there is no money to pay for any of it.

Reply
Comment_arrow

Robert "Bobby" Saltzman

8:32 am on Tuesday, March 5, 2013

Spoken like a true TEA Partier Sharon...now get the facts• The federal government will pay for most (90% - 100%) of the Medicaid expansion when it is implemented in 2014, but states would be required to pay for up to 10% percent of it by 2020.. It is a small price to pay to assure everyone has acess to health care.
Your I got mine and you can take a flying leap is what is wrong is Tally....

sharon poole

8:37 am on Tuesday, March 5, 2013

Bobby, I am not a Tea Partier. You have no idea who I am. People that try to slap labels on others have low intelligence. And have you ever gone to the doc with Medicaid? You have no idea how bad it is.

Reply
Comment_arrow

Peggy Jamison

11:27 am on Tuesday, March 5, 2013

You obviously have no idea how bad it is not to be able to get ANY treatment because you are SICK! Out of work because you are SICK! Out of insurance because you are SICK! Out of money to pay for meds because you are SICK! Maybe ins does need reform, but they are greedy mongers and have had the world of time to police themselves. They won't. This has got to be the first step to taking some of the power away from them and giving it back to the people who pay for their yachts and palaces. If I had all the money I've paid into health ins all these years, I wouldn't need it now! And as far as medicaid Dr's, Every Dr I've known that took medicare... IE my doctor (I'm too young to get medicare and don't "qualify" for medicaid) my Mom's Dr, my Dad's Dr, and a dozen or so others are wonderful people and have much more care for people in general than you obviously do! If that makes me have LOW INTELLIGENCE then so be it. Maybe that's because I got sick, lost my insurance, couldn't get treatment of any kind, and got told I brought it on myself, I was a MOOCH, and generally a rotten irresponsible person. This helps a LOT when you're just trying to survive...NOT!!! You need to grow some conscience and heart. If you don't like Obamacare (which by the way is NOT the plan Obama's team proposed) then help figure out something better. I've been hanging in the void for 10 years. Something HAS to be done.

Comment_arrow

Robert "Bobby" Saltzman

1:18 pm on Tuesday, March 5, 2013

I said spoken "like" I did not label you...I am on Medicare and still have my same dr from when I was working. He said "no difference"...my "low intelignce" has been around a long time...I am always going to be for the little guy because I am one..

Comment_arrow

Patriot

1:25 pm on Tuesday, March 5, 2013

Sharon: That there is a classic back peddle from Mr.Robert Saltzman! He should be in politics!

Joey Saltzburg

8:37 am on Tuesday, March 5, 2013

Once again idiots abound! Tea stains were made to be removed! 2014 is gonna be fun!

Reply
Comment_arrow

Robert "Bobby" Saltzman

4:22 pm on Tuesday, March 5, 2013

Patriot
1:25 pm on Tuesday, March 5, 2013
"Sharon: That there is a classic back peddle from Mr.Robert Saltzman! He should be in politics"
Wow did i really??? In what way did I backpeddle?? We know your politics do you know mine?...this is politics over people in true form of the TEA Party..tell me how fair and balanaced the current bunch in Tally are...they are saying no because...they got a better idea?? I don't hear them saying they do..all I hear is oh it's gonna cost this or that...$$ vs lives saved!!!

sharon poole

8:39 am on Tuesday, March 5, 2013

And Bobby, I would really like to know how much this 10% comes to. And I also think it is hilarious that you trust the federal government to keep their word, after they have bankrupted this nation and stolen all my retirement.

Reply
Comment_arrow

Peggy Jamison

11:31 am on Tuesday, March 5, 2013

How old are you? Which government stole the money? Hello! The money was there before the Bush came into office, and was gone when he left. Maybe Obama is just trying to figure out how to fix the disaster he was left with!

DRaymond

8:45 am on Tuesday, March 5, 2013

Any surprise that the state legislature of Florida was ranked the most corrupt in the country?

Reply
Comment_arrow

Mark

3:36 am on Wednesday, March 6, 2013

Cite your source DRaymond. If you can't then you should refrain from posting useless comments.

Joey Saltzburg

8:49 am on Tuesday, March 5, 2013

No surprise here! lol Led by the most corrupt of all Tricky Ricky Scott!

Reply

JS

9:08 am on Tuesday, March 5, 2013

Medicaid outcomes have a 50% poorer rate than those of the uninsured. Sounds like a great way to go lol ! http://www.forbes.com/sites/aroy/2011/03/02/why-medicaid-is-a-humanitarian-catastrophe/

Reply
Comment_arrow

Peggy Jamison

11:47 am on Tuesday, March 5, 2013

Your article says "Patients on Medicare were 45% more likely to die than those with private insurance; the uninsured were 74% more likely; and Medicaid patients 93% more likely." That's because at this point, you have to be about to die to get on medicaid! Where as people who are lucky and healthy enough to have insurance get treatment from day one. I've been too ill to work for 10 years (I worked and paid for insurance for 40 before that), but because I'm not basically dying, just poor, but not poor enough for welfare, I can't get medicaid. If medicaid took care of people who were just sick, and not about to die, the numbers would be way different. You don't get on medicaid until your way past getting cured. Plus, I've worked in hospitals, and there's many a person that works there that believes like many here, that if your sick and don't have insurance, your a leach and don't deserve good care. What is the matter with you people? At this point, I begin to wonder if we'll get turned into a pillar of salt!

Greg Giordano

9:35 am on Tuesday, March 5, 2013

Here is the body of an announcement that I posted yesterday on this site which includes the entirety of Representative Mike Fasano's response to the committee's decision:

PART ONE:

Today the House Select Committee on Patient Protection and Affordable Care Act voted to turn down federal dollars to expand Florida’s Medicaid program. State Representative Mike Fasano was both disappointed and critical of the decision.

“By voting to turn back these dollars, this committee has, in essence, told millions of Floridians that they are not worthy of having access to primary health care services,” Representative Fasano states. “Our office receives untold numbers of calls from single women, single mothers and others who may be living on the edge that they cannot see a doctor because they do not qualify for Medicaid under existing criteria.”

The dollars offered by the federal government would have expanded Medicaid eligibility so that many of these constituents would receive health care coverage for years to come.

Reply

Greg Giordano

9:35 am on Tuesday, March 5, 2013

PART TWO:

“Florida’s taxpayers are donors to the federal government,” Representative Fasano states. “The dollars that the federal government offered to the state are dollars that Florida has already sent to Washington. By not accepting these dollars, Florida is not only guaranteeing that people will not get the coverage they need, they are also guaranteeing that those dollars will go to some other state which will gladly accept and use them for their own residents.”

It is estimated that 4 million Floridians would have been eligible for health care coverage if the federal dollars were accepted for Medicaid expansion.

“All we hear in Tallahassee is no, no, no,” Representative Fasano continues. “If it is the leadership’s intent to deny access to primary health care to millions of people currently not covered, then what is leadership’s alternative plan to help their fellow Floridians get the adequate health care services they want and need?”

END

Reply

RD

10:35 am on Tuesday, March 5, 2013

The taxpayers will pay for this one way or the other. If we don't take the federal money, hospitals, doctors, pharmacies, and all the supporting corporations will just raise rates on those of us with insurance and the insurance companies will increase our premiums while limiting further what they cover and how much they pay. There's a great article in Time magazine about the cost of medical care in America.
We
As long as corporations have free reign, we will continue to pay the price until we too, find ourselves in the position of not being able to afford medical care.

Reply
Comment_arrow

Peggy Jamison

11:36 am on Tuesday, March 5, 2013

Well said. If we don't get some kind of care for the uninsured, they end up on the welfare roles and medicare / medicaid eventually which costs the taxpayer way more in the long run than just providing health care in the first place, so they can get well and go back to work!

Who is WILLIAM BINNEY?

11:36 am on Tuesday, March 5, 2013

Rick Scott, his wife and the other medical industry criminals would have made money off of the expansion. Some are probably incensed by this no. Scott's decision had nothing to do with "politics," it was all about money for his family and his criminal cohorts.

Do you not remember what industry they have been involved with for years?? Upon implementation, we would have witnessed a dramatic increase in the Solantic facilities accepting Medicaid. Either way.....whether implemented or not, Solantic and the Scott's are going to be making money from the taxpayers.

And everybody needs to seriously awaken to the reality of why we have such horrendous health care and exorbitant prices........Govt intervention. Blame the Govt involvement and not any other group. We need to have a major shift in consciousness in this country and world.

Every single area Govt is involved lowers the quality and increases prices.

People blame colleges for high tuition prices.....they would NEVER reach present heights without Govt subsidizing a large majority of the enrollment nationwide.

People blame Dr's, hospitals, insurance providers, corporations for ever increasing medical prices............they would NEVER reach the present insanity without Govt subsidizing services.

How about the "housing crisis??" It would have NEVER happened without Govt involvement.

GOVT ISN'T THE SOLUTION.............GOVT IS THE PROBLEM.

Reply

Who is WILLIAM BINNEY?

11:50 am on Tuesday, March 5, 2013

And for the clueless believing those against this are somehow heartless.........please inform me the justification of stealing from group A to give to group B is heartfelt???

I know Robin Hood is lauded as a hero, but his actions aren't what was advocated by the Christ person when he stated..."whatever you did unto the least of these." Thievery is thievery regardless of the intention and I and many others are tired of having the fruits of our labor stolen to supposedly help others. You who love all these Govt programs......do your chains rattle when you type your brainwashed responses??

People weren't dying in the streets prior to Govt intervention in medicine. Heck, prior to Govt involvement, there were more charity hospitals......and......hospitals and Dr's provided at least 10% of their services free of charge. With the Govt involved, what percentage do you think is free of charge now?? Charity work is practically non-existent.

I know so many people receiving Govt "benefits"......if these so called safety nets were removed, the majority of them have family they would rely on. I know multiple family members living separately in HUD housing while family members have plenty of space for both. When can we start being humans again? Family should be taking care of family, not relying on the Govt.

By the way, even though we are looted to fund these social programs, Americans still give more to help their fellow man in America and worldwide than Govt.

Reply

Who is WILLIAM BINNEY?

12:00 pm on Tuesday, March 5, 2013

By the way, when are we going to advocate healthy living in this country, opposed to the present medical model of toxification?

People would be better off avoiding the MD's unless they need something fixed like a broken bone. Allopathic medicine isn't the answer to the woes of the country. It is actually leading to much of the carnage we are witnessing all around us.

Most a brainwashed into believing Allopathy is THE only form of medicine and the MD's practicing it are THE only Dr's. This couldn't be further from the truth.

Many with ailments could heal themselves WITHOUT visiting a MD. I guarantee at least one person reading this can heal themselves if they start listening to truth and not lies.

http://www.gcnlive.com/programs/brightSide/

Listen to this show for a few weeks and if your brain still works, you will realize much of what you have been told is a freaking lie. Avoid being a customer of the medical industry and start taking care of yourselves through natural remedies. Geesh, people hate the oil industry as they gladly gobble up the petroleum based pharmaceuticals. Oh the insanity.

Listen and learn.
http://www.gcnlive.com/programs/brightSide/

Reply

sharon poole

12:42 pm on Tuesday, March 5, 2013

There is a lot of ignorance on this thread that I can't even begin to address.

Reply
Comment_arrow

Michael D.

1:48 pm on Tuesday, March 5, 2013

and how is you adding this comment moving the conversation forward. Just another label among people who are labeling.

Comment_arrow

Peggy Jamison

2:48 pm on Tuesday, March 5, 2013

shallow, shallow people who don't have any care for those worse off than themselves! Hope your luck runs out like mine did, but at least I tried to help others when I was well and doing better. I didn't act like they were second class citizens because they weren't lucky enough to have been where I was to get ahead. Making judgments is the worst sin.

Dharma

2:39 pm on Tuesday, March 5, 2013

and there is no such thing as medicad and obamacare, what it states if if any state isnt going to use the money it recieves each year for medicad then it cant ask for it. as they have been ritually each year! know ur facts

Reply
Comment_arrow

Peggy Jamison

2:51 pm on Tuesday, March 5, 2013

I'm confused by your statement.. guess I'm one of the ignorant ones... :) Are you saying Florida has been asking for aid for medicare every year? What does that have to do with Obamacare... I know it's medicare, of course, but if they refuse it, does it cause a problem with the regular medicare funding?

Comment_arrow

Mark

3:58 am on Wednesday, March 6, 2013

Dharma, you should have spent a little more time paying attention in English class instead of passing notes. You writing skills are horrible! But I suspect they are in line with all your other skills as well...lol

Mike Funkhowser

3:43 pm on Tuesday, March 5, 2013

Our legislators can stick their heads in the sand all they want. Pam Bondi can appear on Fox News railing against Obamacare all she wants, but it does not negate the FACT that the Affordable Care Act is the law of the land, upheld by the Supreme Court. They can hate on Obama all they want. They can pretend the results of the 2012 election didn't occur. Sorry, the AFA is coming whether they like it or not. Time to get their noses out of the lobbyists rears and actually lead. Did we hear the same people singing the blues that we couldn't afford Medicare Part D when Bush and the Republicans decided to give all Medicare participants drug coverage during the time of major defecits and unfunded wars?

Reply
Comment_arrow

Mark

3:32 am on Wednesday, March 6, 2013

Yeah Mike...Obamacare is coming alright, along with America's bankruptcy - "like it, or not". So when our currency collapses, and as we enter into an economic depression that will make the "Great" one of the 1930's pale by comparison, I will give you and your Liberal cohorts full credit. If anyone has their head in the sand it is you, and if anyone needs to lead it is supposed to be the President, but all he is leading us to is bondage and despair. You better put down the Kool Aid and drink a big glass of reality before its too late!

Comment_arrow

Michael D.

9:05 am on Wednesday, March 6, 2013

Mark,
Like Mike Mirra above your bias is showing here. To blame just the Democrats is as wrong as blaming just the Republicans. Both parties have gotten us into the mess we are. Let us not forget it was the Bush Administration that pulled away from the policies of Reagan, Bush Sr. and Clinton from a strong dollar monetary policy to a weaker dollar economic policy. These problem fall on both parties, because both parties have been spending without taking in revenue. Creating loopholes for their "donators". The Affordable Healthcare Act is one of many cash cows of the Federal Government. Remember that 11 Trillion of the 16 Trillion of the yearly deficit according to the Treasury Department Reports are legislation that was signed off by the Bush Administration. So don't blame just one side for the mess we are in.

nancy

12:16 pm on Thursday, March 7, 2013

Well, here is the short version answer to the question posed by PATCH.ORG:
No to increased medicaid benefits for the state of Florida!

Reply

pat cawley

6:50 am on Saturday, March 9, 2013

Would be smarter for the state to have health care available to more people because 1. a healthy state is attractive to big business to move to the state 2. hospitals wouldn't go bankrupt because they cannot take the medicare cuts 3. why have the people of florida bail out their hospitals constantly 4. its cheaper to pay for someone to go to the doctor on a regular then to wait for them to get sicker and have to be hospitalized then can't pay so floridians end up paying.

Reply
Comment_arrow

Peggy Jamison

2:55 pm on Monday, March 11, 2013

Wow, you said it so much better than I did! Thanks!

Don Lack

10:48 am on Tuesday, March 19, 2013

The Patch should know that this is called the Affordable Healthcare Act, not Obamacare.

Reply
Comment_arrow

Mark

12:13 pm on Tuesday, March 19, 2013

Perfect name for you Mr. Lack, because you clearly "lack" the knowledge that Obama embraced the term Obamacare and now uses it himself.

Typical of a Liberal to whine about something so mundane, when the real problem is "how do we retract this monstrosity before it consumes us all?".

Michael D.

12:33 pm on Tuesday, March 19, 2013

Mark,
Embracing a term that was created by a Republican Lobbyst and coined by Romney. The fact that Obama got ahead of it and used it in a speech, doesn't change the fact it is the incorrect name being used by a news organization. Their used to be standards in this country regardless of party, and apparently when those standards do not fit your cause your ok with allowing them to be overlooked. The problem in this country is the partisanship which you displayed so evidently with your labeling of "Liberal". Thank you for continuing the lowering of the standards in this country Mark to fit your political agenda.
When we start thinking as Americans instead of labels is the point we can move forward as a society. But as shown very obviously in this thread, we do not have the collective intelligence or want to do so.

Reply

JR

2:01 pm on Tuesday, March 19, 2013

Michaeal D-
You mean like the term "tea bagger" or "repugs" or "repubtards" which many on the left including the media like to use on a regular basis? Who made you the gatekeeper of what words are acceptable and which ones are not? Liberal is a word just like conservative that refer to political ideologies that have been used for a long time. Get off your moral high horse and get over yourself...nobody cares what people call each other on the Patch and you are not going to change anyone's mind or political agenda. Political partisenship is how it works in our country and our politicians are masters at pointing fingers and not accepting any blame. Maybe you should take your no label campaign to Washington DC and see how far you get.

Reply
Comment_arrow

Michael D.

4:05 pm on Tuesday, March 19, 2013

JR,
The words themselves are not the problem, the problem is we as a society have become stuck behind said words. And it also allows those political finger points to have the power. You complain about them with the words they give you to complain about them with. Until we start thinking like Americans, and fixing American problems. Not what some label did that is against what my label says to do. The "Liberals", "Conservative", "Tea Baggers" didn't do this, we did by allowing them to divide and control us. Then we just continue this spiral downwards. The fact that you take offense to some and not others just shows you are just as wrapped up in the propaganda they have feed you to be wrapped up in.
I don't plan on changing the agenda of people who do not want to change. Just pointing out that you are part of the same problem you are so eager to complain about. At some point America will wake up and see the theatre that has been given instead of leadership, hopefully it will not be too late. If Political Partianship is what works why do the same corporations own both parties, as always follow the money. Money is what runs this system, because we allow it to.

Dan Pressler

7:03 pm on Tuesday, March 19, 2013

did you know the dems are proposing 1.2 Trillion in tax increases over 10 years - in part to pay for Obama-care & the other social programs - that works out to 120 Billion per year. With 300 million (round numbers) that is about $400/year for every man woman a child currently in the US. I can guarantee that obama has no interest in balancing the budget - he said as much - just taxing us into oblivion

Reply
Comment_arrow

Patriot

1:28 pm on Friday, March 29, 2013

Obama has no good intention, in anything he does....or says... he is a traitor to the American people that he was elected to serve! He should be...at the least...impeached....at the most....imprisoned!

Magnus Thunderson

2:45 pm on Saturday, May 4, 2013

There are a lot of misconceptions about heath care in the USA So here is the truth
1) Everyone is covered
2) Uninsured are only covered by the far most expensive system we have which are hospitals
3) Other are covered by local health care which in Tampa cost us 1 cent in sales taxes and other such as women centers and free clinics
4) Medicare is an expensive program but is the most efficient in the industry and Medicaid is even more efficient but harsher to those unlucky to be on it but it better than no insurance like a very large part of our county
5) We spend more on health care in the USA than any other first world country and were no were near the best coverage or care in the world.
6) Every one against single payer points to Canada however Canadian are very happy with their pain and if we switched to their plan we save four trillion a year according to what we pay for health care and Canada pays for health care based on GDP.
7) Switch to a single payer plan will case layoff of 15 thousand or more jobs at more the 3000 health plans company’s in the USA but also would make us much more able to play in the world market as every employer worries about health care cost and why so much has moved over seas.

Reply
Comment_arrow

Magnus Thunderson

2:47 pm on Saturday, May 4, 2013

one other thing we could spend a little more like most first world countrys and do better then canada

Leave a comment